Original source: Barack Obama’s Siri Fort speech not a ‘parting shot’ at BJP: White House
More: New Delhi and Beijing reaffirm ties following President Obama’s India trip
View post: Chemistry between Obama, Modi to drive Indo-US ties, says American Senator
See original article: The Modi effect: PM’s mention of Benjamin Franklin’s autobiography sparks sales
Original link: Dil ki Baat: PM Modi, Obama turn ‘Mann ki Baat’ into gooey love-fest
After the morning’s pregnant-with-hidden-meaning remarks by Barack Obama on the need for religious tolerance in India, the evening’s Mann ki Baat featuring him and Narendra Modi turned into a veritable love-fest between a US President and an India’s Prime Minister.
Efficiently RJ-ed by Modi, the Tuesday night radio programme was carefully choreographed to focus on softball issues that few could misinterpret. It was converted into a veritable Dil ki Baat rather than just a Mann ki Baat. Not surprising, since Obama had already spoken what was on his ‘mann’ at Siri Fort, a speech that was read differently by Modi baiters and Modi bhakts.
But Modi had no intention of turning his pet programme into a controversial discussion on all kinds of ideas. He deftly anchored the discussion away from hard political topics to gooey, sentimental stuff that could not go wrong.
Customers at a radio and tv shop listen to Mann ki baat
This is not to cynically dismiss the Mann ki Baat as just goody-goody stuff, for we got nuggets of info about Modi that we have never heard of before. Throughout the programme, Modi played generous host to Obama’s courteous guest.
Despite the elaborate answers from Obama on everything from bringing up daughters to dealing with obesity to what inspires him to the role of today’s youth in a globalised world, it was Modi who dominated the radio show by bringing in his own heroes, his own anecdotes, and generally presenting us with his softer side. This is not the side we usually get to see of Modi.
His reason for bringing out the soft stuff is best explained in his own words: “If we discuss what comes from the heart, and repeat it, hum it, we get a new energy.” (Read the full transcript of their conversation here)
Modi’s research team obviously must have done some homework before the programme, for he began by trying to give us the meaning of Barack. He said: “In Swahili language, which is spoken in parts of Africa, Barack means one who is blessed. I believe, along with a name, his (Obama’s) family gave him a big gift.”
The reference to Barack’s African lineage allowed him to link an Upanishadic idea with an African one. “African countries have lived by the ancient idea of ‘Ubuntu’, which alludes to the ‘oneness in humanity’. They say, ‘I am, because we are’. Despite the gap in centuries and borders, there is the same spirit in Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam (the world is one family), which (we) speak of in India. This is the great shared heritage of humanity. This unites us.”
When he lobbed the ball to Obama, the latter talked about how Modi and he were making “a lot of history in a short time.” It was a reference not only to the India-US nuclear and other agreements of the previous two days, but also to the fact that this was the first ever visit by a US president on Republic Day, and the first-ever joint radio programme involving two top leaders of the world’s biggest democracies.
A subtle difference in how Obama and Modi saw the world was the former’s efforts to bring in god into the conversation. At Siri Fort, where Obama talked of the need for countries to ensure religious freedom, he had referred to his Christian faith. He said: “In our lives, Michelle and myself have been strengthened by our Christian faith.” In Mann ki Baat, Obama exhorted everyone to “endeavour to seek God through the service of humanity because God is in everyone.”
Modi, despite references to Swami Vivekananda, Mahatma Gandhi and Upanishadic ideas, made no direct references to God. Americans apparently need God more than Indians, despite the ubiquity of temples and mosques in India.
Also interesting was Modi’s choice of heroes. He mentioned Henry David Thoreau, who inspired Gandhi’s civil disobedience movement, John F Kennedy (Modi liked his personality), Martin Luther King, and, most importantly, Benjamin Franklin, one of the founding figures of America, author, politician, scientist and many other things. Modi had an epiphany after reading Franklin’s biography. “I find his life truly inspiring. And I tell you too, if you read his biography, you will find ways to transform your life too.”
What Modi liked about Benjamin Franklin was his ability to talk about everyday issues and how to deal with them. Questions like: “If we feel excessively sleepy, how can we reduce that? If we feel like eating too much, how can we work towards eating less? He has addressed such issues in his biography. And I tell everyone, we should read Benjamin Franklin’s biography. Even today, it inspires me.”
What Modi and Obama found they had in common was their humble origins, with both recounting the time when they looked at the White House from the outside, little imagining that one day they would both meet inside it. One of the listeners to the radio programme apparently remarked that he had seen a photo of Modi standing outside the White House when he had gone there as a tourist. The photo apparently shows Modi looking at the White House from outside an iron fence.
It gave Modi an opportunity to relate a story about Obama’s gift to him when he went to the White House last September as an official guest. “When I visited the White House, one thing touched my heart. I can never forget that Barack gave me a book, a book that he had located after considerable effort. That book had become famous in 1894. Swami Vivekananda, the inspiration of my life, had gone to Chicago to participate in the World Religions Conference. And this book was a compilation of the speeches delivered at the World Religions Conference. That touched my heart. And not just this. He turned the pages of the book, and showed me what was written there. He had gone through the entire book! And he told me with pride, I come from the Chicago where Swami Vivekananda had come.”
Relating the incident also allowed Modi to repeat his favourite phrase that becoming Prime Minister was never his goal. He said: “For a long time, I have been telling everyone, never dream of becoming something. If you wish to dream, dream of doing something. Don’t dream of becoming something, dream of doing something.”
Obama, for his part, also talked about his own outside-in look at the White House in his youth.
“When I first went to the White House, I stood outside that same fence, and looked in, and I certainly did not imagine that I would ever be visiting there, much less living there. You know, I think both of us have been blessed with an extraordinary opportunity, coming from relatively humble beginnings. And when I think about what’s best in America and what’s best in India, the notion that a tea seller, or somebody who’s born to a single mother like me, could end up leading our countries, is an extraordinary example of the opportunities that exist within our countries.”
The only hint of Mann ki Baat’s tangentially political messaging came when Modi talked about Communism in the past tense. He said: “Once upon a time, there were people inspired primarily by the Communist ideology. They gave a call: ‘Workers of the world, Unite.’ This slogan lasted for several decades. I believe, looking at the strength and reach of today’s youth, I would say, ‘Youth, Unite the world’. I believe they have the strength and they can do it.
That’s as subtle a put-down of the Left as you can get.
“The world will be more secure if United States and India share values,” US President Barack Obama said during his address on All India Radio’s Mann Ki Baat show, where Prime Minister Narendra Modi addresses the nation every month.
Sharing their personal experiences, both Obama and Modi spoke of how if one is determined enough, they can achieve their goals irrespective of their family backgrounds.
President Barack Obama and PM Narendra Modi recording ‘Mann Ki Baat’ show in New Delhi. PTI
US President Barack Obama’s address at Delhi’s Siri Fort Auditorium on Tuesday – his last engagement before he flew off to Saudi Arabia – where spoke extensively on the important role of women in building society and also stressed that the United States was India’s best partner in ensuring both the nations move forward together.
Barack Obama at Siri Fort Auditorium. PTI
And just in case you missed it, here is the complete video.
Islamabad: Peeved at the breakthrough in the operationalisation of the Indo-US nuclear deal, Pakistan on Tuesday said the move for “political and economic expediencies” would have a “detrimental” impact on deterrence stability in South Asia.
Hours after US President Barack Obama concluded his unprecedented second visit to India, Pakistan Prime Minister’s Adviser on National Security and Foreign Affairs Sartaj Aziz opposed India’s bid for membership to the 48-member Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) and a permanent seat in the UN Security Council.
Representational image. AFP
“The operationalisation of Indo-US nuclear deal for political and economic expediencies would have a detrimental impact on deterrence stability in South Asia. Pakistan reserves the right to safeguard its national security interests,” he said.
During his three-day visit, Obama held wide-ranging talks with Prime Minister Narendra Modi as both countries broke a seven-year logjam to operationalise a landmark civil nuclear deal, besides enhancing defence and trade ties.
Apart from clearing the obstacles for the implementation of the civil nuclear deal, President Obama reaffirmed the US’ position that India is ready for NSG membership.
Reacting to the US’ backing to India’s NSG membership bid, Aziz said, “We have also noted the Joint Statement suggesting that India is ready for NSG membership and other export control regimes.
“Pakistan is opposed to yet another country-specific exemption from NSG rules to grant membership to India, as this would further compound the already fragile strategic stability environment in South Asia, would further undermine the credibility of NSG and weaken the non-proliferation regime.”
Aziz asserted that Pakistan remains opposed to policies of “selectivity and discrimination”.
“Pakistan is not averse to civil nuclear cooperation and NSG membership for non-NPT states provided it is based on the principles of non-discrimination and objective non- proliferation criteria,” he said.
He reiterated that Pakistan would continue to maintain its constructive engagement with NSG and other export control regimes to build its case for membership.
Aziz also opposed India’s permanent UNSC membership bid, saying, “A country, in violation of United Nations Security Council resolutions on matters of international peace and security, such as the Jammu and Kashmir dispute, by no means qualifies for a special status in the Security Council.”
During his India visit, President Obama also reaffirmed his support for a reformed UN Security Council with India as a permanent member.
(Hon’ble Shri Narendra Modi):
Today, Shri Barack Obama, President of the United States, joins us in a special programme of Mann Ki Baat. For the last few months, I have been sharing my “Mann Ki Baat” with you. But today, people from various parts of the country have asked questions.
But most of the questions are connected to politics, foreign policy, economic policy. However, some questions touch the heart. And I believe if we touch those questions today, we shall be able to reach out to the common man in different parts of the country. And therefore, the questions asked in press conferences, or discussed in meetings – instead of those – if we discuss what comes from the heart, and repeat it, hum it, we get a new energy. And therefore, in my opinion, those questions are more important. Some people wonder, what does “Barack” mean? I was searching for the meaning of Barack. In Swahili language, which is spoken in parts of Africa, Barack means, one who is blessed. I believe, along with a name, his family gave him a big gift.
Good friends. PTI
African countries have lived by the ancient idea of ‘Ubuntu’, which alludes to the ‘oneness in humanity’. They say – “I am, because we are”. Despite the gap in centuries and borders, there is the same spirit of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, which speak of in India. This is the great shared heritage of humanity. This unites us. When we discuss Mahatma Gandhi, we remember Henry Thoreau, from whom Mahatma Gandhi learnt disobedience. When we talk about Martin Luther King or Obama, we hear from their lips, respect for Mahatma Gandhi. These are the things that unite the world.
Today, Barack Obama is with us. I will first request him to share his thoughts. Then, I and Barack will both answer the questions that have been addressed to us.
I request President Barack Obama to say a few words.
(Hon’ble Shri Barack Obama):
Namaste! Thank you Prime Minister Modi for your kind words and for the incredible hospitality you have shown me and my wife Michelle on this visit and let me say to the people of India how honoured I am to be the first American President to join you for Republic Day; and I’m told that this is also the first ever Radio address by an Indian Prime Minister and an American President together, so we’re making a lot of history in a short time. Now to the people of India listening all across this great nation. It’s wonderful to be able to speak you directly. We just come from discussions in which we affirmed that India and the United States are natural partners, because we have so much in common. We are two great democracies, two innovative economies, two diverse societies dedicated to empowering individuals. We are linked together by millions of proud Indian Americans who still have family and carry on traditions from India. And I want to say to the Prime Minister how much I appreciate your strong personal commitment to strengthening the relationship between these two countries.
People are very excited in the United States about the energy that Prime Minister Modi is bringing to efforts in this country to reduce extreme poverty and lift people up, to empower women, to provide access to electricity, and clean energy and invest in infrastructure, and the education system. And on all these issues, we want to be partners. Because many of the efforts that I am promoting inside the United States to make sure that the young people get the best education possible, to make sure that the ordinary people are properly compensated for their labour, and paid fair wages, and have job security and health care. These are the same kinds of issues that Prime Minister Modi, I know cares so deeply about here. And I think there’s a common theme in these issues. It gives us a chance to reaffirm what Gandhi ji reminded us, should be a central aim of our lives. And that is, we should endeavour to seek God through service of humanity because God is in everyone. So these shared values, these convictions, are a large part of why I am so committed to this relationship. I believe that if the United States and India join together on the world stage around these values, then not only will our peoples be better off, but I think the world will be more prosperous and more peaceful and more secure for the future. So thank you so much Mr. Prime Minister, for giving me this opportunity to be with you here today.
(Hon’ble Shri Narendra Modi):
Barack the first question comes from Raj from Mumbai
His question is, the whole world knows about your love for your daughters. How will you tell your daughters about youre experience of India? Do you plan to do some shopping for them?
(Hon’ble Shri Barack Obama):
Well first of all they very much wanted to come. They are fascinated by India, Unfortunately each time that I have taken a trip here, they had school and they couldn’t leave school. And in fact, Malia, my older daughter, had exams just recently. They are fascinated by the culture, and the history of India, in part because of my influence I think, they are deeply moved by India’s movement to Independence, and the role that Gandhi played, in not only the non-violent strategies here in India, but how those ended up influencing the non-violent Civil Rights Movement in the United States. So when I go back I am going to tell them that India is as magnificent as they imagined. And I am quite sure that they are going to insist that I bring them back the next time I visit. It may not be during my Presidency, but afterwards they will definitely want to come and visit.
And I will definitely do some shopping for them. Although I can’t go to the stores myself, so I have to have my team do the shopping for me. And I’ll get some advice from Michelle, because she probably has a better sense of what they would like.
(Hon’ble Shri Narendra Modi):
Barack said he will come with his daughters. I extend an invitation to you. Whether you come as President, or thereafter, India looks forward to welcoming you and your daughters.
Sanika Diwan from Pune, Maharashtra has asked me a question. She asks me, whether I have sought assistance from President Obama for the Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao Mission
Sanika you have asked a good question. There is a lot of worry because of the sex ratio in India. For every 1000 boys, the number of girls is less. And the main reason for this is that, there is a defect in our attitudes towards boys and girls.
Whether or not I seek help from President Obama, his life is in itself an inspiration. The way he has brought up his two daughters, the way he is proud of his two daughters.
In our country too, I meet many families who have only daughters. And they bring up their daughters with such pride, give them such respect, that is the biggest inspiration. I believe that inspiration is our strength. And in response to your question, I would like to say, to save the girl child, to educate the girl child, this is our social duty, cultural duty, and humanitarian responsibility. We should honour it.
Barack, there is a question for you. The second question for President Obama comes through e-mail: Dr. Kamlesh Upadhyay, a Doctor based in Ahmedabad, Gujarat – Your wife is doing extensive work on tackling modern health challenges like obesity and diabetes. These are increasingly being faced in India as well. Would you and the First Lady like to return to India to work on these issues after your Presidency, just like Bill and Melinda Gates?
(Hon’ble Barack Obama):
Well, we very much look forward to partnering with organizations, and the government and non-governmental organizations here in India, around broader Public Health issues including the issue of obesity. I am very proud of the work that Michelle has done on this issue. We’re seeing a world-wide epidemic of obesity, in many cases starting at a very young age. And a part of it has to do with increase in processed foods, not naturally prepared. Part of it is a lack of activity for too many children. And once they are on this path, it can lead to a life time of health challenges. This is an issue that we would like to work on internationally, including here in India. And it is a part of a broader set of issues around global health that we need to address. The Prime Minister and I have discussed, for example, how we can do a better job in dealing with issues like pandemic. And making sure that we have good alert systems so that if a disease like Ebola, or a deadly flu virus, or Polio appears, it is detected quickly and then treated quickly so that it doesn’t spread. The public health infrastructure around the world needs to be improved. I think the Prime Minister is doing a great job in focusing on these issues here in India. And India has a lot to teach many other countries who may not be advancing as rapidly in improving this public health sector. But it has an impact on everything, because if children are sick they can’t concentrate in school and they fall behind. It has a huge economic impact on the countries involved and so we think that there is a lot of progress to be made here and I am very excited about the possibilities of considering this work even after I leave office.
(Hon’ble Shri Narendra Modi):
Mr. Arjun asks me a question. An interesting question. He says he has seen an old photo of me as a tourist outside the White House. He asks me what touched me when I went there last September.
It is true that when I first went to America, I was not lucky enough to visit the White House. There is an iron fence far from the White House. We stood outside the fence and took a photograph. White House is visible in the background. Now that I have become Prime Minister, that photo too has become popular. But at that time, I had never thought that sometime in my life, I would get a chance to visit the White House. But when I visited the White House, one thing touched my heart. I can never forget that. Barack gave me a book, a book that he had located after considerable effort. That book had become famous in 1894. Swami Vivekananda, the inspiration of my life, had gone to Chicago to participate in the World Religions Conference. And this book was a compilation of the speeches delivered at the World Religions Conference. That touched my heart. And not just this. He turned the pages of the book, and showed me what was written there. He had gone through the entire book! And he told me with pride, I come from the Chicago where Swami Vivekananda had come. These words touched my heart a lot. And I will treasure this throughout my life. So once, standing far from the White House and taking a photo, and then, to visit the White House, and to receive a book on someone whom I respect. You can imagine, how it would have touched my heart.
Barack there is a question for you. Himani from Ludhiana, Punjab. Question is for you ……:
(Hon’ble Shri Barack Obama):
Well the question is “Did you both imagine you would reach the positions that you’ve reached today?”
And it is interesting, Mr. Prime Minister, your talking about the first time you visited White House and being outside that iron fence. The same is true for me. When I first went to the White House, I stood outside that same fence, and looked in, and I certainly did not imagine that I would ever be visiting there, much less living there. You know, I think both of us have been blessed with an extraordinary opportunity, coming from relatively humble beginnings. And when I think about what’s best in America and what’s best in India, the notion that a tea seller or somebody who’s born to a single mother like me, could end up leading our countries, is an extraordinary example of the opportunities that exist within our countries. Now I think, a part of what motivates both you and I, is the belief that there are millions of children out there who have the same potential but may not have the same education, may not be getting exposed to opportunities in the same way, and so a part of our job, a part of government’s job is that young people who have talent, and who have drive and are willing to work for, are able to succeed. And that’s why we are emphasizing school, higher education. Making sure that children are healthy and making sure those opportunities are available to children of all backgrounds, girls and boys, people of all religious faiths and of all races in the United States is so important. Because you never know who might be the next Prime Minister of India, or who might be the next President of United States. They might not always look the part right off the bat. And they might just surprise you if you give them the chance.
(Hon’ble Shri Narendra Modi):
Thank you Barack.
Himani from Ludhiana has also asked me this question – did I ever imagine I would reach this high office?
No. I never imagined it. Because, as Barack said, I come from a very ordinary family. But for a long time, I have been telling everyone, never dream of becoming something. If you wish to dream, dream of doing something. When we do something, we get satisfaction, and also get inspiration to do something new. If we only dream of becoming something, and cannot fulfil the dream, then we only get disappointed. And therefore, I never dreamt of becoming something. Even today, I have no dream of becoming something. But I do dream of doing something. Serving Mother India, serving 125 crore Indians, there can be no greater dream than this. That is what I have to do. I am thankful to Himani.
There is a question for Barack from Omprakash. Omprakash is studying Sanskrit at JNU. He belongs to Jhunjunu, Rajasthan. Om Prakash is convener of special centre for Sanskrit Studies in JNU.
(Hon’ble Shri Barack Obama):
Well this is a very interesting question. His question is, the youth of the new generation is a global citizen. He is not limited by time or boundaries. In such a situation what should be the approach by our leadership, governments as well as societies at large.
I think this is a very important question. When I look at this generation that is coming up, they are exposed to the world in ways that you and I could hardly imagine. They have the world at their fingertips, literally. They can, using their mobile phone, get information and images from all around the world and that’s extraordinarily powerful. And what that means, I think is that, governments and leaders cannot simply try to govern, or rule, by a top-down strategy. But rather have to reach out to people in an inclusive way, and an open way, and a transparent way. And engage in a dialogue with citizens, about the direction of their country. And one of the great things about India and the United States is that we are both open societies. And we have confidence and faith that when citizens have information, and there is a vigorous debate, that over time even though sometimes democracy is frustrating, the best decisions and the most stable societies emerge and the most prosperous societies emerge. And new ideas are constantly being exchanged. And technology today I think facilitates that, not just within countries, but across countries. And so, I have much greater faith in India and the United States, countries that are open information societies, in being able to succeed and thrive in this New Information Age; than closed societies that try to control the information that citizens receive. Because ultimately that’s no longer possible. Information will flow inevitably, one way or the other, and we want to make sure we are fostering a healthy debate and a good conversation between all peoples.
(Hon’ble Shri Narendra Modi):
Omprakash wants me too, to answer the question that has been asked to Barack.
Barack has given a very good answer. It is inspiring. I will only say, that once upon a time, there were people inspired primarily by the Communist ideology. They gave a call: Workers of the world, Unite. This slogan lasted for several decades. I believe, looking at the strength and reach of today’s youth, I would say, Youth, Unite the world. I believe they have the strength and they can do it.
The next question is from CA Pikashoo Mutha from Mumbai, and he asks me, which American leader has inspired you
When I was young, I used to see Kennedy’s pictures in Indian newspapers. His personality was very impressive. But your question is, who has inspired me. I liked reading as a child. And I got an opportunity to read the biography of Benjamin Franklin. He lived in the eighteenth century. And he was not an American President. But his biography is so inspiring – how a person can intelligently try to change his life.
If we feel excessively sleepy, how can we reduce that?
If we feel like eating too much, how can we work towards eating less?
If people get upset with you that cannot meet them, because of the pressure of work, then how to solve this problem?
He has addressed such issues in his biography. And I tell everyone, we should read Benjamin Franklin’s biography. Even today, it inspires me. And Benjamin Franklin had a multi-dimensional personality. He was a politician, he was a political scientist, he was a social worker, he was a diplomat. And he came from an ordinary family. He could not even complete his education. But till today, his thoughts have an impact on American life. I find his life truly inspiring. And I tell you too, if you read his biography, you will find ways to transform your life too. And he has talked about simple things. So I feel you will be inspired as much as I have been.
There is a question for Barack, from Monika Bhatia.
(Hon’ble Shri Barack Obama):
Well the question is “As leaders of two major economies, what inspires you and makes you smile at the end of a bad day at work?”
And that is a very good question. I say sometimes, that the only problems that come to my desk are the ones that nobody else solves. If they were easy questions, then somebody else would have solved them before they reached me. So there are days when it’s tough and frustrating. And that’s true in Foreign Affairs. That is true in Domestic Affairs. But I tell you what inspires me, and I don’t know Mr. Prime Minister if you share this view – almost every day I meet somebody who tells me, “You made a difference in my life.”
So they’ll say, “The Health-Care law that you passed, saved my child who didn’t have health insurance.” And they were able to get an examination from a Physician, and they caught an early tumour, and now he is doing fine.
Or they will say “You helped me save my home during the economic crisis.”
Or they’ll say, “I couldn’t afford college, and the program you set up has allowed me to go to the university.”
And sometimes they are thanking you for things that you did four or five years ago. Sometimes they are thanking you for things you don’t even remember, or you’re not thinking about that day. But it is a reminder of what you said earlier, which is, if you focus on getting things done as opposed to just occupying an office or maintaining power, then the satisfaction that you get is unmatched. And the good thing about service is that anybody can do it. If you are helping somebody else, the satisfaction that you can get from that, I think, exceeds anything else that you can do. And that’s usually what makes me inspired to do more, and helps get through the challenges and difficulties that we all have. Because obviously we are not the only people with bad days at work. I think everybody knows what it is like to have a bad day at work. You just have to keep on working through it. Eventually you make a difference.
(Hon’ble Shri Narendra Modi):
Indeed Barack has spoken words from the heart (Mann Ki Baat). Whatever position we may hold, we are human too. Simple things can inspire us. I also wish to narrate an experience. For many years, I was like an ascetic. I got food at other people’s homes. Whoever invited me, used to feed me as well. Once a family invited me over for a meal, repeatedly. I would not go, because I felt they are too poor, and if I go to eat at their place, I will become a burden on them. But eventually, I had to bow to their request and love. And I went to eat a meal at their home. It was a small hut, where we sat down to eat. They offered me roti made of bajra (millet), and mik. Their young child was looking at the milk. I felt, the child has never even seen milk. So I gave that small bowl of milk to the child. And he drank it within seconds. His family members were angry with him. And I felt that perhaps that child has never had any milk, apart from his mother’s milk. And maybe, they had bought milk so that I could have a good meal. This incident inspired me a lot. A poor person living in a hut could think so much about my well-being. So I should devote my life to their service. So these are the things that serve as inspiration. And Barack has also spoken about what can touch the heart.
I am thankful to Barack, he has given so much time. And I am thankful to my countrymen for listening to Mann Ki Baat. I know radio reaches every home and every lane of India. And this Mann Ki Baat, this special Mann Ki Baat will echo forever.
I have an idea. I share it with you. There should be an e-book made of the talk between Barack and me today. I hope the organizers of Mann Ki Baat will release this e-book. And to you all, who have listened to Mann Ki Baat, I also say, do participate in this. And the best hundred thoughts that emerge out of this, will also be added to this e-book. And I want you to write to us on Twitter, on Facebook, or online, using the hashtag #YesWeCan.
• Eliminate Poverty – #YesWeCan
• Quality Healthcare to All – #YesWeCan
• Youth empowered with Education – #YesWeCan
• Jobs for All – #YesWeCan
• End to Terrorism – #YesWeCan
• Global Peace and Progress – #YesWeCan
I want you to send your thoughts, experiences and feelings after listening to Mann Ki Baat. From them, we will select the best hundred, and we will add them to the book containing the talk that Barack and I have had. And I believe, this will truly become, the Mann Ki Baat of us all.
Once again, a big thank you to Barack. And to all of you. Barack’s visit to India on this pious occasion of 26th January, is a matter of pride for me and for the country.
Thank you very much.
New Delhi: Bollywood superstar Shah Rukh Khan on Tuesday said he was proud to get a mention in US President Barack Obama’s speech on gender and religious equality.
Obama charmed the crowd while addressing a Town hall event in Siri Fort on the third and final day of his visit to India by quoting Shah Rukh Khan’s famous line ‘Senorita, bade bade deshon mein…’ from blockbuster Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge.
Shah Rukh Khan.
The actor’s name cropped up again in his address as the President picked Shah Rukh, sports icons like Milkha Singh and Mary Kom and Nobel laureate Kailash Satyarthi’s names to make a point about humanitarian values.
“Proud to be part of the gender and religion equality speech of President Obama. Sad he couldn’t do the Bhangra… next time Chaiyya Chaiyya for sure,” Shah Rukh tweeted.
“Why didn’t Hamid Ansari salute the national flag?” Even as the country celebrated its 66th republic Day, this was what was seemed to be topmost on the minds of the self-proclaimed defenders of patriotism, in a disturbing incident of religious stereotyping that is absolutely against everything republic day stands for.
Social media went into a tizzy yesterday, criticising the vice president by posting pictures on Twitter and Facebook showing that Ansari did not salute the national flag during the national anthem.
Home minister Rajnath Singh and external affairs minister Sushma Swaraj didn’t salute the flag either, but their patriotism was not questioned.
“Jihadi sympathiser”, “anti-India”, “traitor”, were among the hate tweets that were hurled at the vice president of India. Some even demanded that Ansari be impeached, and the more outraged ones advised him to join the ISIS.
It’s shame for us Our vice president Mr. Ansari not salute at flag hosting Plz spread dis tweet. pic.twitter.com/by88KQBUka
But well, Twitter was wrong. Ansari was not required to salute as per the protocols.
According to Section VI of the Flag Code of India, “During the ceremony of hoisting or lowering the flag, or when the flag is passing in a parade or in a review, all persons present should face the Flag and stand at attention. Those present in uniform should render the appropriate salute”.
So, except for the President of the country, no one is required to salute. Prime Minister Narendra Modi, vice president Ansari, US President Barack Obama, defence minister Manohar Parrikar were not in uniform and were therefore not required to salute the flag.
The tweets were so disturbing that Ansari’s office issued a statement clarifying why it wasn’t wrong not to salute.
“As per the protocol, when the national anthem is played, the Principal Dignitary and persons in uniform take the salute. Those in civil dress stand in attention. “During the Republic Day Parade, the President of India, as Supreme Commander, takes the salute. As per protocol, the Vice President is required to stand in attention,” Gurdeep Sappal, Joint Secretary and OSD to the Vice President, said in a statement.
“When the Vice President is the Principal Dignitory, he salutes during the national anthem, wearing headgear, as done at NCC camp this year,” Sappal added.
What is disturbing is, why would Ansari need to prove his patriotism? Just because he is a Muslim?
Outrage about Hamid Ansari is a bit silly. Saluting national flag is not mandatory. You stand up during the anthem, and he was doing that
In fact, as many on social media pointed out, our earlier Prime Ministers also did not salute the flag during the Republic Day celebrations and that includes BJP’s Atal Vihari Vajpayee.
But of course, he wasn’t required to prove his patriotism.
Originally posted here – Live: Modi wishes Obamas a safe journey, quotes DDLJ for rainy Republic Day
Link – Not just impressing Obama, what the all-women contingent on Republic Day really did
Excerpt from: Live: Obama to end 3-day India visit with Town Hall at Siri Fort Auditorium
Original post: Sticky issues: Why was President Obama chewing gum at R-Day parade?
Original article: President Obama to meet Kailash Satyarthi, address event at Siri Fort in Delhi
Credit: First ever all-women contingent marches through the 66th Republic Day Parade
Source: Modi, Obama bonhomie on display at Republic Day parade
Read this article – Operationalising the Indo-US nuclear deal: Here’s what the impasse was all about
Continue reading: Pleased with tangible progress on key issues with India: US
Taken from: Obama in India: Issues like LGBT rights, forced labour that went unheard
Source: Obama promises Modi to look into India’s concerns on H-1B visa issue
Read this article – Live: Growth can’t be measured by GDP, it has to make life better, says Obama
Originally from: Live: President Obama meets who’s who of India Inc; PM Modi, Jaitley present
Visit site: Republic Day: 7-layer security ring at Rajpath
Originally posted here: Congress chief Sonia, ex-PM Manmohan call on Barack Obama
See the original article here: From Modi to Manmohan: Leaders across parties attend R-Day parade with Obama
View original article: Naming and shaming Pak’s terror outfits is key takeaway from POTUS’ India visit
Read this article: Craving US approval: Indian media’s obsession with Obamas is overdone
Read this article: India displays diverse cultural heritage, military might on Republic Day
Visit source: Live: Obama leaves R-day parade, will have lunch with Sonia, Rahul
Source article: 7-layer security ring to 15,000 CCTV cameras: unprecedented security for R-day
Link to original: Hugs, chai pe charcha and hotline for chatting: The fascinating bromance of Modi, Obama
Originally from: PM Modi wins big with US nuclear deal, but will Obama want in return?
Read the article: Breakthrough: India-US end six-year-old impasse over civil nuclear deal
View this article: Live: I wanted to wear PM Modi’s kurta, says Obama at Rashtrapati Bhavan
Link: Live: Obamas arrive for Presidential dinner at Rashtrapati Bhavan
Excerpt from: Breakthrough: India-US end six-year-old logjam over civil nuclear deal
Continue reading: Barack and I: The new political bromance of Modi and Obama on display for world
View original post here: US President Obama Visit: India, US renew their 10 year Defence Framework Agreement
Taken from: India not to display Agni-V missilies during Republic Day parade
See the original post: From Malpua to Galauti Kebab: Presidential dinner for Obama has all the flavours of India
View this article: Live: Modi gifts Obama copy of first telegram from US to India’s Assembly
Source: Sealed with a hug: Modi, Obama make cute new BFFs
Continued here – Live: Modi receives Obama, Michelle as Air Force One lands in Delhi
Continue reading: With Liability Clause settled, will Obama clear nuke deal by dumping flagging issue?
Originally posted here: Ahead of Air Force One landing, Delhi turns into a fortress for Obama visit
Link: Obama visit: India, US hope to make progress in nuclear, defence, technology transfer
More – Timeline: Obama and Modi will try to get nuclear deal over the line
More: Live: Air Force One takes off for New Delhi with Barack and Michelle Obama on board
View the original here: India set to showcase defence might on Republic Day
Source: Security arrangements for Obama’s visit: India agrees to no fly zone, high rise buildings to be shut
Read the article – Obama won’t visit Taj Mahal as India trip cut short, will head to Saudi Arabia
More: India-US ties cements further on Obama-Modi bonhomie, say experts
Continued: Timeline: R-Day parade, ‘walk and talk’ on Barack Obama’s India schedule
View original: Photos: Dress rehearsal for the Republic Day parade, India gears up for Obama’s visit
Visit link: Photos: Full dress rehearsal for the Republic Day parade takes place ahead of Obama’s visit
Jump to original: Ahead of Obama’s visit, India may add sovereign guarantee to nuke deal with US
Original source: Pakistan proceeding strictly to ban Hafiz Saeed’s JuD and Haqqani, says Abdul Basit